Sign up for regular news, views and insights about corporate governance

Job title


Setting the benchmark in corporate integrity

UK’s FRC rejects calls for compulsory audit rotation

Despite pressure to encourage greater competition in the UK’s accounting market, regulator waters down its proposed rule changes

Although it had hinted at imposing mandatory audit rotation when it began its review of the rules governing the UK’s accountancy market, the Financial Reporting Council (FRC) has turned its back on the proposals that many observers felt would lead to a more transparent market.

The UK’s Competition Commission announced proposals to force FTSE 350 companies to put out to tender every five years audit work; a much harder stance than the FRC’s proposed ten year tendering requirements.

However, the FRC is said to be concerned about the impact such regular tendering would have on company operations and the costs linked to tendering for new auditors. While the Competition Commission was keen to force a more level playing field on the market, it has stopped at making compulsory auditor changes necessary for leading companies.

This represents a considerable scaling back of the enforced rotation that many had been calling for to ensure transparency within the UK’s biggest companies, as well as the leading audit firms.

Dominated by the Big Four accounting firms, the UK’s audit market has come under scrutiny after a number of high profile cases showed too cosy a relationship between both the companies being audited and the firm scrutinising them.

Deloitte, PricewaterhouseCoopers, Ernst & Young and KPMG have a hold on the UK’s accounting market, and smaller firms – including BDO and Grant Thornton – have called for changes to rules that would mean they have a fairer chance of getting business.

European discussions
A consequence of the UK’s caution over imposing such strict rules is that they are forced to adhere to those drawn up in Brussels. The EU has been keen to make the accountancy industry more competitive and transparent, and one British MEP has proposed mandatory rotation every 14 years.

Sajjad Karim MEP drafted the reforms in April, which he said would ensure transparency, but not too frequently as to restrict a company’s competitiveness. In light of the FRC’s proposals, Karim told Corporate Governance Report: “The findings from the UK Competition Commission confirm that a package of measures are required to resolve concerns about standards in markets for audit services. I have long called for any concerns for standards to be addressed by relevant national competition authorities, and am satisfied by those provisional remedies identified in the UK.”

“The UK commission findings chime with my proposals adopted at the European level, which recognise that any reforms need to be carefully weighed and should not have an adverse effect on the market. I have above all emphasised the importance of the audit committee when devising the European reforms, something which the Competition Commission has also taken on board.”

Karim is keen to point out that making companies rotate their auditors too frequently would hinder their ability to be competitive: “Forcing companies to rotate after a short period of time is detrimental to audited companies and auditors alike; it flies in the face of our goal of restoring trust in the financial system and ensuring the highest quality audit services are available for shareholders and investors.”

He added: “Auditors require a sufficient length of time to ensure the audit process is carried out judiciously, but we must also recognise that some tenures may be perceived as too long. This fine line is something we need to get right. We need auditors and companies to be able to focus on the audit, and shareholders and investors to have confidence in this process.”

European-wide reforms for auditing are expected to be voted on towards the end of this year by the European Parliament, and Karim believes that a deal will be struck: “Our work at European level continues with the hope that a conclusion can be reached by the end of the year. I am confident that European lawmakers can resolve their present differing opinions, and the reforms agreed will be of great benefit to financial reporting and corporate governance across Europe.”



FRC report reveals highs and lows of UK governance

A recent report by the FRC reveals the extent by which recent reforms have changed corporate governance in the UK, as well as the effect non-compliance has had on the organisation’s finances

NSE establishes Corporate Governance Index

The NSE has partnered with the CBi in an attempt to offset perceptions of Nigerian capital markets being riddled with corruption

Norway appoints corporate governance board

In a bid to become a more active investor, Norway has appointed a corporate governance advisory board to help oversee its $760bn sovereign wealth fund

Gulf Keystone Petroleum clash with top investor over structure demands

City investor M&G has ruffled feathers at Gulf Keystone after telling the oil company it needs to appoint non-executive directors to its board

Tech Data delays annual report after regulator questions

US-based technology wholesaler made to delay the publication of its annual report after questions are raised about accounting practices of its UK subsidiary

Australian government launches mining probe

Australia’s securities regulator is set to launch a probe of the country’s biggest mining companies in a bid to crack down on selective briefings

Reducing annual report clutter

The presence of clutter in an annual report actively detracts from its usefulness to both shareholder and investor alike

Strategic CSR stops small companies being overshadowed

The 2013 Ethics and Leadership Conference has highlighted the need for companies within the same industry to group together to exercise their corporate social responsibility

Pay ratio disclosure leaves directors unconvinced

The SEC’s recent pay ratio proposal has given rise to criticism and suggestions that it is an ineffective way of curbing excessive executive pay

Italian banks to “change corporate governance”

Banks with more out-dated corporate governance structures were hit hardest by crisis, according to Fitch statement

Motorola announces support for 30 Asia-Pacific education initiatives

The Motorola Solutions Foundation Grants will affect 79,000 individuals

Deutsche ordered to improve internal controls

Imminent order by German regulator is likely to lead to Deutsche Bank reaching a settlement over Libor scandal

ASIC pushes ahead with annual report reforms

Australian regulator demands more information on strategy from public companies in their annual financial statements

About the awards

The Corporate Governance Report Awards celebrates leaders and innovators in financial reportage, transparency and shareholder relations. We identify those organisations setting the standard in internal …